Positive and negative toolingArray drawing reviewOptical inspection
Home / Master-to-replica comparison and molding defects

Master-to-replica comparison and molding defects

Compare the master, negative cavity and replicated array to investigate a visible difference during a cosmetic tooling review.

Compare corresponding locations

Place the master view, cavity view and finished sample view in order. Check the same corner or row on each item and account for the reversed surface relationship. Without a location map, an apparent difference can result from comparing unrelated areas.

Four micro-CT panels showing a master, a positive replica, an inverse mold and a section through the master.
Master, mold and replica in micro-CTFaraji Rad and colleagues imaged the three physical stages and included a master section for comparison.
Image creditsZahra Faraji Rad, Robert E Nordon, Carl J Anthony, Lynne Bilston, Philip D Prewett, Ji-Youn Arns, Christoph H Arns, Liangchi Zhang and Graham J Davies · Image source · CC BY 4.0 · Original figure proportions and markings retained; converted to WebP.
Four grayscale micrographs of a replicated array, an individual feature, its tip and a connecting channel.
Replica array and feature detailThe researchers documented the same replica design at array and feature scale.
Image creditsZahra Faraji Rad, Robert E Nordon, Carl J Anthony, Lynne Bilston, Philip D Prewett, Ji-Youn Arns, Christoph H Arns, Liangchi Zhang and Graham J Davies · Image source · CC BY 4.0 · Original figure proportions and markings retained; converted to WebP.

Name the observation before the cause

A partial-looking feature, a bent edge and material visible inside a cavity are different observations. Mark what the photograph actually shows and keep any explanation as a question for the supplier. A section or another orientation may be needed to resolve an ambiguous image.

Define the next sample decision

If the difference affects an agreed visual or dimensional requirement, identify the affected features and the next evidence needed. A new image can resolve a viewing issue. A newly identified change to the tool or sample should receive its own record and approval.

Did the reported change occur at the master, mold or replica stage?

In the Faraji Rad study, the authors measured the master, mold and final replica against the design. For buyer review, a single percentage labelled “replication” needs the same clarity. Ask which two objects were compared and which dimension produced the percentage. For example, an overall width can agree while a particular feature height differs. Keep both original readings, their units and the stage identities so the comparison can be recalculated when a revised drawing arrives.

Faraji Rad et al. (2017) · Three-dimensional comparison of master, mold and replica

Master-to-replica comparison and molding defects
Research figure · Tim Evens, Sylvie Castagne, David Seveno & Albert Van Bael (2022) · Fig. 8. Open figure and credit · CC BY 4.0

Prepare your inquiry

Trace one feature through the master, cavity and sample.

Select the items you want to ask about.